Skip to main content

Update: The Steep Costs of a Republican Default Crisis

Key Points:
If the GOP pushes the United States into a protracted default, 8.3 million people would lose their jobs this summer as the unemployment rate spikes to 8.6%, and real GDP shrinks by 6.1 percentage points.
That would be the largest drop in employment in United States history that was not caused by a global pandemic.
The costs of this default calamity would not be in the same universe as the costs of a government shutdown. While the $5 billion (adjusted for inflation) hit to the economy caused by the most recent shutdown in 2018 is by no means trivial, it pales in comparison to the $1.6 trillion drop in GDP if the United States enter into a protracted default.
Breaching the debt limit would be catastrophic, but even the threat of breaching the debt ceiling can have serious economic consequences for families. A new homeowner could see their monthly mortgage payment go up nearly $160 thanks to Republicans’ debt limit threats, costing them an extra $58,000 over the life of their loan.

Republicans have now pushed the United States to within one month of a catastrophic and unprecedented default on the nation’s existing obligations. Instead of passing a clean debt limit bill to avert this crisis, their continued threats to cause a default could trigger a massive recession that would cost 8.3 million Americans their jobs.

The longer the GOP delays in paying our bills, the more likely they are to drive up the cost of mortgages and threaten people’s retirement savings. The debt ceiling is not a bargaining chip, and Congress must act to cover existing obligations before the American people start to pay the cost of a default crisis.

This is an update to the Joint Economic Committee Democrats’ earlier work on the cost of the GOP default crisis. This document includes new numbers on the risk to the economy and updated figures on the increase in mortgage costs. These are just some of the ways that the GOP’s reckless plan will harm people across the country. The first report includes data on how a default harms veterans, Social Security beneficiaries, and people with public health insurance.

Instead of following this dangerous path, Republicans should join Democrats in avoiding a default and passing a clean debt-limit bill like they did three times under the last president.

A default on our existing obligations would cause massive job losses

A recent analysis by the Council of Economic Advisors lays out the steep economic costs of failing to pay our existing obligations. If the GOP pushes the United States into a protracted default, 8.3 million people would lose their jobs this summer as the unemployment rate spikes to 8.4%, and real GDP shrinks by 6.1%.

That would be the largest drop in employment in United States history that was not caused by a global pandemic. Unlike during the COVID-19 recession, however, the government would be unable to send out stimulus checks, boost unemployment insurance, and prevent evictions to cushion the blow. This would be a catastrophic and completely avoidable economic crisis.

Even a brief period of default would shrink GDP by nearly $159 billion while eliminating 500,000 jobs. And despite House GOP claims that their bill represents a reasonable offer, a recent analysis by Moody’s Analytics’ found that the Default on America Act would cost the United States 780,000 jobs over the next year and increase the chance of a recession.

The effects of a default are enormous compared to those of a shutdown

The costs of this default calamity would not be in the same universe as the costs of a government shutdown. While the $5 billion (adjusted for inflation) hit to the economy caused by the most recent shutdown in 2018 is by no means trivial, it pales in comparison to the $1.6 trillion drop in GDP if the United States enters into a protracted default.

The effects of a shutdown are more limited to a smaller set of “non-essential” government operations, whereas the effects of a default are broad, massive, and difficult to predict. We know our economy can bounce back quickly from a shutdown but an unprecedented default would test the limits of the economy’s resilience and will have long-lasting consequences.

Republicans’ decision to push the United States to the brink of default will push up costs for families

Breaching the debt limit would be catastrophic, but even the threat of breaching the debt ceiling can have serious economic consequences. In 2011, debt limit brinkmanship pushed up interest rates on mortgages by up to 70 basis points. If this pattern held again, a new homeowner could see their monthly mortgage payment go up nearly $160 thanks to Republicans’ debt limit threats, costing them an extra $58,000 over the life of their loan. The table below shows what these costs would be in all 50 states plus DC.

The threat of default could also make the average worker close to retirement take a $20,000 hit to their retirement savings according to analysis by Third Way, increase the cost of a small business loan by $2,500, and drive up the cost of a car loan by over $800.

Debt Limit Brinkmanship Could Push Mortgage Costs Higher in Every State

State

Median Listed
Home Price

Increase in
Monthly Payment

Lifetime Cost of
Higher Payments

Alabama

$330,000

$120

$44,000

Alaska

$415,000

$160

$56,000

Arizona

$495,000

$190

$67,000

Arkansas

$289,900

$110

$39,000

California

$750,000

$280

$101,000

Colorado

$639,925

$240

$86,000

Connecticut

$559,900

$210

$75,000

Delaware

$494,900

$180

$67,000

District of Columbia

$649,999

$240

$87,000

Florida

$467,990

$170

$63,000

Georgia

$395,400

$150

$53,000

Hawaii

$852,500

$320

$115,000

Idaho

$574,900

$210

$77,000

Illinois

$310,000

$120

$42,000

Indiana

$299,900

$110

$40,000

Iowa

$315,000

$120

$42,000

Kansas

$314,825

$120

$42,000

Kentucky

$299,950

$110

$40,000

Louisiana

$289,250

$110

$39,000

Maine

$425,000

$160

$57,000

Maryland

$420,000

$160

$57,000

Massachusetts

$759,000

$280

$102,000

Michigan

$280,000

$100

$38,000

Minnesota

$400,000

$150

$54,000

Mississippi

$279,900

$100

$38,000

Missouri

$300,000

$110

$40,000

Montana

$660,000

$250

$89,000

Nebraska

$371,900

$140

$50,000

Nevada

$475,000

$180

$64,000

New Hampshire

$549,000

$210

$74,000

New Jersey

$518,000

$190

$70,000

New Mexico

$375,000

$140

$50,000

New York

$639,945

$240

$86,000

North Carolina

$419,720

$160

$56,000

North Dakota

$332,060

$120

$45,000

Ohio

$249,900

$90

$34,000

Oklahoma

$315,000

$120

$42,000

Oregon

$569,900

$210

$77,000

Pennsylvania

$290,000

$110

$39,000

Rhode Island

$525,500

$200

$71,000

South Carolina

$359,925

$130

$48,000

South Dakota

$369,900

$140

$50,000

Tennessee

$444,900

$170

$60,000

Texas

$384,900

$140

$52,000

Utah

$619,900

$230

$83,000

Vermont

$447,250

$170

$60,000

Virginia

$449,000

$170

$60,000

Washington

$649,000

$240

$87,000

West Virginia

$229,900

$90

$31,000

Wisconsin

$374,900

$140

$50,000

Wyoming

$459,000

$170

$62,000

 

 

 

 

United States

$430,000

$160

$58,000

 

 

 

 

Sources: Realtor.com residential listings database, Mortgage Bankers Association's Weekly Mortgage Applications Survey

Note: Values are rounded to the nearest dollar, and calculations use 6.5% as the baseline mortgage rate. Elevated mortgage rates reflect a 0.7% increase to the baseline, as seen in 2011. Data are the most recent available and refer to April 2023 for the median listed home price by state and the week ending in April 28, 2023 for the national average contract interest rate for 30-year fixed-rate mortgages with conforming loan balances and an 80% loan-to-value ratio.